Feb 21, 2014; Orlando, FL, USA; New York Knicks small forward Carmelo Anthony (7) reacts after being called for a foul in the fourth quarter as the Orlando Magic beat the New York Knicks 129-121 in double overtime at Amway Center. Anthony had a game-high 44 points. Mandatory Credit: David Manning-USA TODAY Sports

New York Knicks: Did Knicks Make a Mistake Not Completing a Trade?


The New York Knicks are 0-2 since Thursday’s trade deadline came and went. They’ve suffered a loss to the lowly Orlando Magic in a double overtime game, and then they blew a double-digit lead to the Atlanta Hawks, who were on an eight-game losing streak prior to last night.

With the Knicks falling further out of the playoff picture (they’ve never really been in it), the question begs to be asked: should the Knicks have made a trade before the deadline?

Granted, there weren’t any really great offers, but it’s not as if this current club has much going for it, anyway. This doesn’t mean the Knicks should have just dumped off assets or made a trade for the sake of making one. Though the lack of action was disappointing, but Steve Mills and James Dolan were careful not to get pulled into giving up a pick or Tim Hardaway Jr. However, this roster looks like it needs a shake-up.

So it’s hard to say the Knicks should have made a deal while applauding them for not getting suckered into a bad one. But currently, this team is 21-35. There are 26 games remaining. If the Knicks went .500 the rest of the way, which would be an improvement (they’re 2-8 in their last ten), they’d still only have a 34-48 record — hardly desirable. Heck, even if the Knicks won 75% of their games from here on out — 20 wins, rounded — they’d finish with a 41-41 record. Is a .500 season really the end goal? It would put them in about the 5th or 6th seed in the East, and if they were lucky, they’d win one round of the playoffs, but how much is that worth?

The worst part of this recent skid is the tell-tale signs that things aren’t improving. Carmelo Anthony has been going off offensively, and it hasn’t had an effect. Raymond Felton has stepped up his play considerably the last two games — nothing. Tyson Chandler is looking a little more spry, but it hardly matters. Since Andrea Bargnani’s injury and the return to small ball, a movement many felt could turn around the season, the Knicks have had the fourth best offensive rating in the league, but the sixth worst defensive rating. Their offensive potency doesn’t even matter; the team is 6-8 since Bargnani’s injury.

The Knicks should have been trying their best to acquire assets — young, cheap players or draft picks. It’s easier said than done, but it’s the better outcome to this season. The Knicks wouldn’t necessarily have to tank, but if they miss the playoffs, at least they could have still had some youth and a pick. And if they did miss the playoffs, that pick could’ve been in the lottery (so long as it’s not too highly protected). For now, the Knicks have a hole to crawl out of to make the playoffs, despite how little it may really mean.

Follow Scott Davis on Twitter.

Follow and Like Buckets Over Broadway on Twitter and Facebook.

Tags: Carmelo Anthony Featured NBA Trade Deadline New York Knicks Popular Raymond Felton Tyson Chandler

  • mike

    The real problem here is not just staying pat at trade deadline, its a ton of other things this pathetic organization continues to do year in year out. for starters how does an organization flat out quit on a season??? on its own team and the fans??? to come out and say (we are focused on the 2015 season? by not firing mike woodson, by not finding a way to trade. and yes by not even trading Carmelo. more than likely he walks at years end and the knicks get nothing! wouldn’t you? I am ashamed at being a knicks fan still. but ill continue speaking my mind. im not giving one dime to anything dolan owned period.