Oct 11, 2013; Toronto, Ontario, CAN; New York Knicks forward Andrea Bargnani (77) shoots a free throw as former teammates and Toronto Raptors point guard Kyle Lowry (7) and guard DeMar DeRozan (10) look on at Air Canada Centre. Mandatory Credit: Tom Szczerbowski-USA TODAY Sports

New York Knicks: Should we be concerned about Andrea Bargnani?

When the New York Knicks made the move to acquire former No. 1 overall pick Andrea Bargnani, I could have been counted among those that were very skeptical of the decision.

The theory on paper made sense as Bargnani should be a guy that could stretch the floor, making things a bit easier for the likes of Carmelo Anthony to get to the basket.

However stretching the floor with success on paper is one thing. Doing it on the floor when it matters is something entirely different altogether.

Oct 11, 2013; Toronto, Ontario, CAN; New York Knicks forward Andrea Bargnani (77) holds the ball as he is guarded by Toronto Raptors center Amir Johnson (15) at Air Canada Centre. The Raptors beat the Knicks 100-91. Mandatory Credit: Tom Szczerbowski-USA TODAY Sports

While Bargnani has the ability to be a top-notch scorer on this Knicks team, I was cautious of which player the Knicks were acquiring.

Bargnani is a guy who saw his field goal percentage dip in each of the past three seasons, after shooting a career-high 47 percent from the floor during the 2009-10 campaign. He bottomed out last season when he failed to make 40 percent of his attempts.

Even more concerning to me was the fact that he would be filling a role on this team as a long-range shooter, something Bargnani has not done well the past couple of seasons, knocking down only 29.6 percent of his three-point attempts in 2011-12 and only 30.9 percent last season.

Now many Knicks fans will lead you to believe that Bargnani will be great in blue-and-orange because “he doesn’t have to be the main option.”

That’s another theory I don’t buy.

For Bargnani to be successful in this Knicks’ offense, it all comes down to him making shots. You can say he will stretch the floor all you want, but until he shows he is capable of doing so; teams will still clamp down on Anthony and allow Bargnani to throw up as many bricks as he wants.

That’s something he has done a lot of this preseason.

Bargnani had another rough night Monday against the Toronto raptors, going only 4-for-12 from the floor. Even worse was the fact that he can’t hit an outside shot, going just 2-for-7 when shooting beyond 15 feet.

That’s been a huge problem this preseason as Bargnani has made just 9-of-25 shot attempts outside of 15 feet. If you are scoring at home, that’s only a 36 percent clip.

I tend to not  to draw much conclusion from preseason numbers as most of the time they are meaningless, but in the case of Bargnani, after his past two down seasons, you have to wonder if this is a negative trend.

He’s only played in five games and he is working himself back into shape, so it’s not time to panic just yet, but I would be a little concerned.

Bargnani simply has to shoot the ball much better for this Knicks team to maximize their potential.

The Knicks didn’t trade Marcus CambySteve Novak, a No. 1 pick and two No. 2 picks to bring in a guy that struggles to shoot 40 percent from the floor.

As the preseason winds down, Bargnani is one player worth keeping an eye on.

The bottom line is that he needs to be much better when the Knicks open up their season October 30 against the Milwaukee Bucks.

Follow Matt Shetler on Twitter for news, reaction and analysis from around the NBA.

Follow Buckets Over Broadway on Twitter and on Facebook


Tags: Andrea Bargnani NBA Offseason New York Knicks

  • 2damkule

    at the risk of inviting bad karma (i’m a raps fan, after all), i hope he does manage to turn around his current trajectory. all i can say is that all that you wrote in terms of what it is that it’s HOPED he can bring (an outside threat, floor spacing, etc.) are things that were hoped for in TO for the last 1/2-decade. it’s certainly true that the teams assembled around him were crap, but there’s a bit of a chicken & egg component…a big reason why the team was crap was because that’s what he contributed to it.

    given that no mention has been made of his D & rebounding, i’m assuming that the NYK fanbase is simply assuming that he will provide neither. that’s a good assumption. look, i have nothing against him personally – well, not ‘nothing’ – he never really made any significant improvements to his game, never worked on his weaknesses on either end of the floor, and has had the same physique since he entered the league, so i think it’s fair to question his work ethic at least somewhat, which does get into a more personal critique.

    his skillset is best suited to coming off the bench & being an offensive spark, and that looks like the plan in new york. just an FYI – that was tried in TO, and he never really took to it. small sample size, and he was coming back from injury, so there were other factors, but he never really took to it. it wouldn’t surprise me if it turned out differently in NY, and that he has a season more reminiscent of his earlier days in TO. but he is what he is; as long as he’s not asked to provide any leadership, defense or rebounding, and just focus on being a floor spacer & shot maker, he’ll be fine.

  • johng_3

    Thanks for taking out the garbage Knicks fans. He is eventually going to get injured in the season like he always does. He really has confidence issues as well and that is terrible with a team with JR Smith and MWP on it.