Comments on: Carmelo Anthony: Where Melo Ranks Among Today’s NBA Superstars

By: Wayne Li

Wayne Li — Sun, 03 Jun 2012 00:54:10 +0000

@phildemeo According to your criteria: winning and playoffs. It is reasonable because winning and playoffs create media exposure. If this is the case, why Melo is ahead of Dirk?

By: phildemeo

phildemeo — Thu, 31 May 2012 22:01:36 +0000

I chose my rankings on superstardom, as long as Kobe plays he will be a superstar. Deron and Love don’t have the winning or playoff success to be called superstars nor the appeal league wide. When the Twolves are on the road, prices don’t go up like they do when the Lakers are in. Even though Kevin Love is the best at his position, he is not in the same breathe as Kobe when talking about superstadom. It’s all about what you consider a superstar! I know it’s a different sport, but Josh Hamilton is probably the best player in baseball right now, but is he a bigger star than Derek Jeter?

By: Wayne Li

Wayne Li — Thu, 31 May 2012 21:25:38 +0000

@Scott Davis Kind of agree with you, but this kind of ranking is always argumentative and coming with personal taste.

By: 2012 NBA Playoffs: Why We Should Finally Boycott the NBA Once and for All – Bleacher Report | Free NBA Videos

Thu, 31 May 2012 12:22:45 +0000

[...] team. Immediately following the aftermath of the infamous, disgraceful, fixed 2002 Western …Home » Knicks » Carmelo Anthony: Where Melo Ranks Among Today's NBA SuperstarsBuckets Over Broadway2012 NBA Draft LotteryDime Magazineall 21 news [...]

By: Sports Facts » NBA: Miami Heat rallies to beat Boston Celtics in Game 2 thriller – San Jose Mercury News

Thu, 31 May 2012 09:23:17 +0000

[...] ready' for Game 2 vs. CelticsCBSSports.com (blog)Brisbane Times -Bleacher Report -Buckets Over Broadwayall 3,638 news [...]

By: Scott Davis

Scott Davis — Wed, 30 May 2012 22:25:29 +0000

For all of Kobe’s greatness, he hasn’t been the best player in the league for a few years now. And this season was one of his worst: poor shooting percentages, lower assist numbers, despite an incredibly high usage rate. He’s not really deserving of top 5 players ever, let alone #2.

Likewise for Melo, who had arguably the worst season of his career. Guys like Dirk, D-Will, Westbrook, Love, etc. are all better than Melo, or at least for this past season.

By: NBA 2K12 simulation: Heat vs. Celtics – ESPN (blog) | Free NBA Videos

NBA 2K12 simulation: Heat vs. Celtics – ESPN (blog) | Free NBA Videos — Wed, 30 May 2012 21:00:53 +0000

[...] LeBron James Is Getting OldBleacher ReportNBA PM: James, Wade Realize Full PotentialHoopsWorldHome » Knicks » Carmelo Anthony: Where Melo Ranks Among Today's NBA SuperstarsBuckets Over BroadwaySan Jose Mercury News -MiamiHerald.com -Yahoo! Sportsall 2,805 news [...]